David Aaronovitch and Konstantin Kisin clash over whether we need grand narratives, and what we should do about their disintegration.
Do we crave safety or meaning?
With a free trial, you can watch the full debate NOW at
We think we have an understanding of the present epoch; we are, after all, living in it. But if once we saw ourselves at the edge of history pushing progress forward on all fronts, today many lack an overall account of the world and where we are going. As the French philosopher Lyotard commented: “There has been a collapse of grand narratives and totalizing theories.” History has thrown us from the religious certainty of the pre-modern, to the belief in science and progress of the early and mid-twentieth century, to the postmodern undermining of the very possibility of objectivity and an overall account of the world.
Does the loss of grand narratives threaten our culture and our belief in ourselves? Can we find a new narrative, in the abandonment of metaphysical materialism or in a renewed belief in science? Or do we need to break free of the need for a grand narrative and live fearlessly in the face of the mystery of existence?
#meaning #christainity #marxism
Konstantin Kisin is a Sunday Times best-selling author, comedian, satirist, social commentator and host of the leading YouTube show, TRIGGERnometry. David Aaronovitch is an award-winning journalist, presenter of BBC Radio 4’s Briefing Room, and former long-standing columnist for The Times. Jessica Frazier is a philosopher at the University of Oxford and Fellow of the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies. She is an expert on Indian Philosophy and the European tradition of phenomenology. Hosted by Rana Mitter.
The Institute of Art and Ideas features videos and articles from cutting edge thinkers discussing the ideas that are shaping the world, from metaphysics to string theory, technology to democracy, aesthetics to genetics. Subscribe today!
For debates and talks:
For articles:
For courses:
The Institute of Art and Ideas
source
